Wednesday, June 19, 2013

House adjourns to end volatile year

The House of Commons adjourned for the summer yesterday, as MPs ran wildly back to the school buses dreaming of sprinklers, camp, and hot dogs. Politics on the Hill was starting to get uglier and stupider than usual, so they've all been sent home to cool their hot tempers - as is the case with the rest of us working stiffs. If our employers didn't all give us the summer off, the Stans-in-accounting of the world would be thrown out the windows by August.

It was a rather remarkable year in Ottawa, however. The last of the major party leaders (likely) to contest the 2015 election was named, and the government had to go through one of the most damaging periods any government has suffered since Gomery. How it will all shake out remains to be seen.

But the pace of change in the last 10 months has been extraordinary. The last time we have seen this amount of shifting support in one parliamentary year, an election had been held.

The chart below uses the monthly averages maintained on this site, comparing where things stood when the House of Commons began sitting again after the summer break in September, and where things were when the House adjourned for the summer in June.
With a total change of 32 points in 2012-13, this last season is more similar to 2010-11 than either 2009-10 or 2011-12, and the latter did include a change of leadership for the NDP.

Unfortunately, there have yet to be any polls out in the month of June, so we have to look at where things were in May 2013. But the pace of change has been remarkable. The Conservatives lost six points over the year, while the NDP lost eight and the Liberals gained 18. That is the largest gain in support any party has recently experienced, even more than the 15 points the New Democrats gained between the fall of 2010 and the month after their electoral breakthrough of 2011.

For the Conservatives, the trends are not very positive. In 2011-12 they had dropped six points to around 33%, and had only gained one point during the summer. Then in 2012-13 they dropped another six points. Compared to where the party was two years ago, the Conservatives have lost 13 points. By comparison, the New Democrats are down only seven from June 2011, while the Liberals are up 20 points. This would seem to argue against the perception that the Liberals are making their gains primarily on the backs of the New Democrats. In fact, the Conservatives have suffered most from the arrival of Justin Trudeau, in addition to their own recent spate of stumbles.

But the Liberals shouldn't be counting their chickens already, as the 2010-11 season showed just how much an election can dramatically transform the political landscape. On the other hand, just because things shifted to such a considerable degree in 2011 does not mean that a similar change in fortunes should be expected in 2015. In the 2008 election, for example, the parties ended up generally where they were when the campaign began.

It will be interesting to see what kind of effect the summer will have on these numbers. The Liberals will be looking to maintain their support, while both the Conservatives and New Democrats desperately need to make up some ground. The drop in Conservative support could not have come at a worse time - as you can see on the chart above, the numbers hardly move over the summer. That means there is a good chance that the Conservatives will remain at or below 30% for another two or three months. There is still plenty of time, but that can only be said for so long.


  1. You don't feel "Volatile" could be a slight understatement Eric ??

  2. I expect as the Trudeau honeymoon cools, the Lib numbers will drop some. But because the CPC has a lot of political dragons to fend off these days and the fact that Trudeau seems much more politically astute than he was given credit for, the shift after the honeymoon should not be too dramatic.

  3. I wonder if the Conservatives will fall behind even the NDP.

    Now that would have been a scenario literally nobody would have predicted after the last election. A massive Liberal comeback with them polling in the 40s again, the NDP in opposition, and the Conservatives... languishing in third place.

    1. Unlikely simply because of FPTP. NDP support is concentrated in urban areas where they win with large majorities Tory support is more regionally based throughout the country. Also a strong Liberal party is bad for the NDP; Over the last few months the Liberals have been taking equally from the NDP and Tories but, since the NDP and Grits compete for many of those urban seats the effect is not equally distributed. Finally, as the numbers Peter posted below (which must be taken with a grain of salt since, the poll was not scientific) demonstrate Mulcair has an image problem. After all the bad press the Tories have suffered Mulcair only has a 36% approval rating indicating thus far has been unable to connect with people other than his own supporters. If people don't think you are doing a good job as Opposition Leader they likely will not be inclined to promote you to the top job.

  4. This is the link to a poll/question the CBC's Power and Politics started last night. The results to me are mind-blowing

    Numbers for approval or support

    Which Leader Performed Best

    Trudeau 51%

    Mulcair 36%

    May 8%

    Harper 5%

    Seems the public see's things differently from the pols ??

    1. Hmm, I wasn't able to find said poll. =\
      I would really love to see it!

    2. It was the daily "ballot box" question, which has now been replaced with a question about John Baird. I wouldn't make too much of a fuss over it though as it's about the farthest thing imaginable from a proper scientific poll. It's no secret that CPC supporters are underrepresented among's readership.


    3. Lukas this is one of the big problems with that programs ballot site. The actual question is only available for about 22 hours.

      Sorry but CBC needs to drop this Facebook operated thing !!

    4. It's on the Power and Politics page.


COMMENT MODERATION POLICY - Please be respectful when commenting. If choosing to remain anonymous, please sign your comment with some sort of pseudonym to avoid confusion. Please do not use any derogatory terms for fellow commenters, parties, or politicians. Inflammatory and overly partisan comments will not be posted. PLEASE KEEP DISCUSSION ON TOPIC.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.