Friday, December 21, 2012

2011 vs. 2012 in polls

The year is almost over and the world has not ended just yet. So, what better time to compare the performances of the federal parties in the polls over 2012 to where they stood in 2011 after the election?

I wrote more generally about each party's report card for 2012 at The Huffington Post Canada here. Please check it out.

For this comparison of 2011 to 2012, I did a simple average of every poll that was conducted in each year. For 2011, I only looked at polls taken after the May 2 election. This gives us a very large sample of polls to draw from, and gives us a good picture of where the parties actually won or lost support in 2012. As the years roll on, it will be fascinating to take a look at how 2011 and 2012 compare to 2013, 2014, and beyond.
Nationwide, only the Conservatives lost support. They averaged 37.5% in 2011 but only 33.9% in 2012, a drop of 3.6 points.

But no single party capitalized on it. The New Democrats went from 30.2% in 2011 to 31.2% in 2012, while the Liberals also bumped their support up by a single point (from 21.2% to 22.2%).

Nevertheless, this does show that 2012 has been a bit of a rougher year for the Conservatives. At almost 38%, the party could hope for the kind of ballot-box boost that would give them another majority. At 34%, they would be virtually assured of a minority government.

Considering the surprise breakthrough of 2011, it is perhaps a very good sign for the NDP that they have managed to hold on to their support. While the Liberals might have hoped that 2011 was just a fluke, they can console themselves that they didn't collapse after the debacle of the last election.
The drop in Conservative support was not insignificant in Ontario, where the party went from 39.9% in 2011 to 37.3% in 2012. But the Tories were not alone in slipping, as the Liberals fell 1.5 points to 27.1%.

The New Democrats took full advantage, increasing their support by three points to 28.8% from 25.8%, putting them in second place in the province in 2012.
However, the New Democrats fell sharply in Quebec. The party had maintained most of its support in 2011, with an average of 39.8%, but that slipped by more than four points to 35.7% in 2012.

The Conservatives were also down, dropping to 15.9% from 19.5% in the province.

Both the Liberals and Bloc Québécois were the beneficiaries, with the Liberals up 3.4 points to 19.2% in Quebec in 2012 and the Bloc up 3.8 points to 24.2%, slightly above their May 2011 election result.
The Conservatives lost the lead in British Columbia, averaging 35.7% in the province in 2012 instead of the 39.3% of 2011.

The New Democrats moved ahead with a three-point gain, putting them at 36.3%. The Liberals and Greens held steady, at 18.4% and 8.5% apiece.
The Conservatives and New Democrats slipped a little in Alberta, the Tories falling 2.5 points to 59.9% and the NDP falling 1.5 points to 18.9%. The Liberals made the only gain, going from an average of 9.6% support in the province in 2011 to 13.3% in 2012.
The largest Conservative drop occurred in Atlantic Canada. The party averaged 35.3% in the region in 2011, giving them the lead over the NDP, but fell 5.6 points to only 29.7% in 2012.

The New Democrats upped their support to 34.9% from 31.4%, while the Liberals were up 2.1 points to 29.6% in the region.
The Tories were also down in the Prairies, falling 4.9 points to 44.1%. The NDP was up 2.6 points to 33.8% and the Liberals were up 1.5 points to 15.3% in 2012.

Altogether, 2012 has to be considered a bad year for the Conservative Party. In addition to shedding 3.6 points of support nationwide (or almost 1 out of 10 supporters from their 2011 average), the Conservatives dropped in every region. Some decreases were relatively modest or inconsequential, such as in Alberta and, to a lesser extent, Ontario. But other drops were quite large and would result in the loss of many seats - particularly in British Columbia, Atlantic Canada, and potentially the Prairies.

The four other parties had good years, relatively speaking. The Greens did make a gain of 0.5 points in 2012 and were up in four of the six regions. But they were stagnant in British Columbia and down in Alberta, and their gains in the rest of the country were minimal.

The Bloc Québécois rebounded from a dismal 2011, but at 24.2% support in Quebec in 2012 they are still very close to their disastrous result of the May 2011 election. They are treading water, but that is not quite good enough for a party holding four seats in the House of Commons.

The Liberals had a better year, making a small gain nationwide and upping their support in five of the six regions. However, only their increase in Quebec was substantial and their loss of support in Ontario is proportionately more important. The polls at the end of 2012 suggest that 2013 could be a much better year for the Liberals, though.

The year has to be handed to the New Democrats. Though they did drop in two regions, more than the Liberals, one of them was Alberta where they have few prospects. The slip in Quebec is significant but the party still held a lead in the province in 2012. The gains of three points or more in British Columbia, Ontario, and Atlantic Canada could more than make up for the losses in Quebec, and they are also well placed to win more seats in the Prairies. After such a whirlwind 2011, the New Democrats had the most to lose in 2012 - but kept it together.

With their leadership race coming to a close in April, the Liberals will have the most to gain in 2013. How will the next year play out?


  1. Just curious Éric, but are you going to do endorsement rankings for the Liberal leadership race? It was interesting to see during the NDP and BQ races, and although this seems like less of a race it still would be interesting.

    1. Yes, I'm planning to in 2013. But there aren't many endorsements right now for anyone other than Trudeau, so it might not be so interesting. He'd probably have 90% of the points if I calculated it now.

    2. How about endorsement rankings for the Ontario Liberal leadership race? :)
      Or some other form of coverage.

    3. Why not do one for the provincial Liberals, Eric? There's been a tonne of endorsements for many candidates already.

    4. I might do a tally in the weeks before the convention, but I decided to put the bar at federal leadership races for on-going coverage.

    5. Oh, and I did do a breakdown of endorsements for the Globe a couple weeks back:

  2. Overall, not a bad year for any political party in the federal level. Didn't pundits and commenters think the NDP will collapse? It has not happened yet. In fact, the party gained ground in certain parts of the country, while losing a little a bit of its stance in Quebec. Even under the long dull interim leadership of Nycole Turmel, the party managed to keep afloat.

    The governing Tories were bound to lose some support while governing. I guess they should be glad they did not lose too much support and are still in a stronger position than the other parties. Harper's leadership numbers are steady and the PM has a strong coat of teflon that will guarantee him about 35% of the vote. The winning strategy for the opposition is to reduce the Tories to a minority and form some sort of coalition or arrangement (that does not include the Bloc).

    The Liberals and Bloc are holding strong despite their diminished status. As polls show, if the NDP are under the radar, the Liberals and Bloc get a small bump in the polls. The Liberals are also getting notable support from "soft" Tory voters and this could hold important in the next election. The Greens are doing adequate, but they would only be a factor if they target individual consistencies during the next election.

  3. Basically we can almost say stagnation? Nobody made a "great leap forward" and nobody really fell on their face.

    Which is sort of normal for part way through a majority govt.

    2013 could show the beginning of trends I think ?


COMMENT MODERATION POLICY - Please be respectful when commenting. If choosing to remain anonymous, please sign your comment with some sort of pseudonym to avoid confusion. Please do not use any derogatory terms for fellow commenters, parties, or politicians. Inflammatory and overly partisan comments will not be posted. PLEASE KEEP DISCUSSION ON TOPIC.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.