Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Six months after the federal election

Despite changes in leadership for three of the four opposition parties, the federal voting intentions of Canadians have shifted very little since they cast their ballots six months ago. But contrary to some of the expectations immediately after the results of the federal election became known, the New Democrats are proving to be no flash in the pan.

And the Conservatives may have peaked at the right time.

You can read the rest of the article on The Globe and Mail website here.

If you click on the image to the left you can see the full riding breakdown of this projection, based on the current 308 electoral boundaries.

One of the major shifts is in Saskatchewan, where the New Democrats win a handful of seats. It is a province in which they have historically done well, and it is one of the places where the NDP is likely to make gains in 2015 if they manage to improve their standings in the House of Commons.

Now to something completely different.

Le Nouvelliste, the major newspaper serving Trois-Rivières and the surrounding region, commissioned a poll by Segma Recherche on the voting intentions of Quebecers in Trois-Rivières and Shawinigan. These two cities touch five provincial ridings in the Mauricie: Trois-Rivières, Champlain, and Maskinongé for the former and Laviolette and Saint-Maurice for the latter.

Segma included François Legault's CAQ in the mix, and it gives an idea of how Legault's new party may perform in, at least, the Mauricie. This is not a bad region for the CAQ, considering it has voted for the ADQ in the past. But the poll shows how messy the next election in Quebec could be.
For comparison, I calculated the vote each party received in these five ridings in the 2008 election.

In the three ridings in Trois-Rivières, the Liberals and Parti Québécois were very close, and indeed the Liberals hold two of the ridings and the PQ the other.

In 2008, the Liberals took 39% of the vote in these three ridings, with the PQ taking 37% and the ADQ 20%.

But with Legault's CAQ on the ballot, his party would take the plurality of votes with 29%. The Liberals would drop to 21% and the PQ to only 15%, barely ahead of the ADQ. Also remarkable is the 12% that Québec Solidaire scores, after taking only 2% in the region in 2008.

That the CAQ would win the region with only 29% shows how divided the Quebec electorate currently is. This is not exactly enthusiastic support for Legault, but he could win all three ridings in Trois-Rivières nevertheless.

It is even more divided in Shawinigan. The Liberals and PQ each won a riding here, but overall the Liberals took 48% of the vote in 2008 to the PQ's 35% and the ADQ's 13%.

The Parti Québécois is now narrowly ahead in the city with 25%, but considering the margin of error we're looking at a virtual three-way tie with the CAQ (23%) and the Liberals (22%). The ADQ has held on to its support, while QS is up to 9% in the region.

This means that we would be likely to see a party win one or both ridings in Shawinigan with less than 30% of the vote. Theoretically, the PQ could win them both with only 25% in each riding! For a projection model, this is a nightmare as we could see these kinds of three-way ties across the province.

Mauricie has only five ridings, so it isn't exactly a live-or-die battleground, but this regional poll shows how much trouble the PQ and the Liberals will be in once Legault's party is launched. The Parti Québécois is already being pressed by Québec Solidaire, and with Legault taking a big chunk of their vote as well it isn't impossible that we would see the FPTP system work against the PQ in the worst possible way. Remember that the Bloc Québécois took 23% of the vote in the last federal election, but still won fewer seats than both the Conservatives (17% and five seats) and the Liberals (14% and seven seats). If the splits worked against the PQ in a similar way, we could easily see them reduced to a half-dozen seats in the 125-seat assembly despite taking even a quarter of the popular vote.

But for political junkies like us, it is all very exciting. Quebec is the major political theatre right now and is likely to continue to be so for at least another year. The paperwork has been filed for the launch of the CAQ, and the Option Nationale of Jean-Martin Aussant has already been registered. I don't imagine his party will catch fire, but his party could easily be one of seven that is likely to take at least 2% of the vote in the next election: we have the Liberals, the PQ, the ADQ, Québec Solidaire, the Greens, Legault's CAQ, and now Aussant's Option Nationale. It's getting crowded!


  1. As a politcal nerd, this makes for good show. But it also demontrates that now, more than ever, we need proportional representation in Quebec. With our current system there are often major distortions, but this next election threatens to produce an even more extreme result. A majority government with only 30% support couldn't be good for democracy.

  2. Re: Saskatchewan.

    I can see Noah Evanchuk picking off Ray Boughen in Palliser in the next election.

    As for Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar, unless Nettie Wiebe finally gives it up, I don't know about this one. Saskatoon is getting less NDP one could argue. The older established neighbourhoods in Saskatoon that make this one competitive for the NDP are rapidly losing adherents and need fresh ones.

    The northern riding swings. The NDP would have to recruit a prominent Gary Merasty-type. Lawrence Joseph was a step in the right direction but his time has past.

  3. It's amazing that even when they're in Opposition at their highest levels ever - the NDP are at low levels in the Prairies. I think its more or less clear that both Sask and Man are only going to come home to roost in a wave election for the NDP, otherwise its Conservative for life.

  4. @Eric

    Was there any adjustment made for the... inaccuracies of the polls in the previous election (w.r.t Greens/Tories).


    Manitoba's NDP did pretty well in the last election. I think NDP success in Manitoba-Saskatchewan is possible without a massive wave across the country, but that it'd depend on the federal NDP becoming closer to their Manitoba NDP counterparts (as opposed to closer to the Ontario, BC or other more left-wing provincial wings).

  5. Praxis/Leaderpost poll to be released Thursday/friday on sask election.

    Not sure the NDP are trying anymore. Mandryk has always been a strong proponent of the NDP, but even he is questioning their campaign.

    Could I really save $25,000 in the next 4 years on my tax return?? (an 11% marginal tax rate adds up to less than $17,000 over 4 years on an average income)

    Will potash prices actually climb as the world economy struggles?? The last 5 years have been record years for potash royalties. But the NDP platform is based on an almost doubling of the records (only 2 years after berating the SP for overestimating potash revenues when they collapsed in the recession.)

    It's becoming comical.


COMMENT MODERATION POLICY - Please be respectful when commenting. If choosing to remain anonymous, please sign your comment with some sort of pseudonym to avoid confusion. Please do not use any derogatory terms for fellow commenters, parties, or politicians. Inflammatory and overly partisan comments will not be posted. PLEASE KEEP DISCUSSION ON TOPIC.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.