Thursday, December 2, 2010

Outgoing Williams has best approval rating in Canada

Newfoundland & Labrador Premier Danny Williams' approval rating tops the list of Canadian premiers. He is also only one of three premiers (excluding Prince Edward Island) with a performance that meets the approval of a majority of those who have an opinion.

This Angus-Reid poll shows that most premiers in Canada are pretty unpopular. Only Williams and Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall can be said to have a good approval rating, with 67% and 60% respectively. The premiers of the three largest provinces in the country, meanwhile, are all below 20%.

The following chart shows the approval and disapproval rating of the premiers of Canada's nine largest provinces, after removing those who responded "not sure". While this group was less than 20% of those surveyed in Newfoundland & Labrador, Saskatchewan, Nova Scotia, British Columbia and Quebec, it was over one-third in Manitoba and New Brunswick.It makes for a pretty sorry picture, with only Williams, Wall, and New Brunswick Premier David Alward over 50%.

Excluding Alward, who was elected as the new premier of the province in September, only two premiers have improved their ratings compared to Angus-Reid's similar survey in November 2009. These are Wall (up two points to 60%) and Alberta Premier Ed Stelmach (up seven points to 21%).

Others have remained relatively stable, with Manitoba Premier Greg Selinger dropping one point (to 28%) and Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty dropping two points (to 16%).

But some premiers have seen a sharp drop-off in approval over the last 12 months. British Columbia Premier Gordon Campbell is down five points (16%), Quebec Premier Jean Charest is down nine points (14%), Williams is down 11 points (67%), and Nova Scotia Premier Darrell Dexter is down a whopping 23 points (20%).

Of these nine premiers, two are on their way out. Williams resigned last week and Campbell will leave as soon as a new BC Liberal leader is chosen.

While Alward was just elected, Selinger, McGuinty, and Wall will be facing the electorate in 2011, while Newfoundlanders & Labradorians will be choosing a new premier as well. With these ratings, Wall should be comfortably re-elected. Selinger is in a decent position but McGuinty will have his work cut out for him.

Stelmach and Charest have until 2013 to improve their numbers, though it is becoming more and more unlikely that Charest will be around for that election. Dexter has until 2014, so there is plenty of time for him.

Robert Ghiz, Premier of Prince Edward Island, was not included in this survey. The most recent poll from the Corporate Research Associates, taken in August, showed that 45%, or 64% of those decided, thought him to be the best man for the job.


  1. Poor PEI gets left out again.

    I'd be more interested in seeing the approval ratings of the various Opposition leaders in all the provinces, as opposed to just the Premiers themselves.

    After all, we know that even in BC, Carole James can't make any waves. Even Marois has troubles with the electorate in Quebec. No one seems exactly enthralled with any leaders right now, outside of apparently Ghiz, Wall, and Williams.

  2. I'm amazed McGuinty is over 10% !!

    Obviously has to have more relatives than I thought !!

  3. Looking at just the raw approval numbers, Campbell has a 16% approval rating - his October approval rating was a paltry 9%. McGuinty also has the same 16% raw approval rating. Ouch.

    What surprises me most is the raw approval rating of Dexter at 20%. He was the reason that the NDP won NS government in the first place.

  4. Johnny Quest,

    Too right you are about Dexter. I'm interested in seeing how well Liberal Leader Stephen McNeil is perceived, because I know the polls have been showing the Liberals tied with the NDP lately. Maybe McNeil has some star power, could knock off Dexter in 2013, aye.

  5. The colour scheme is little counter intuitive when one considers that the bottom four premiers are Liberals and four of the top five are Tories.

  6. Dio said...
    "The colour scheme is little counter intuitive when one considers that the bottom four premiers are Liberals and four of the top five are Tories."

    Except for the fact that Charest is a former leader of the federal PC Party and his party has no afilliation to the federal Liberals. Campbell is the leader of one of the more right-wing governemnts in Canada and the party also has no afilliation with the Liberals.

    When will people get this through their heads?

  7. As well Dio Dexter is an New Democrate not a Liberal.

    The only Premier to have an affiliation with the federal Liberals is now only McGuinty.

  8. Campbell's government has ony been right-wing by BC standards. And by those standards it has been very right-wing, but frankly the Alberta Liberals of the 1990s were a more right-wing party than the Campbell Liberals, and they were Alberta's leftist opposition.

    McGuinty has earned that low rating. He's running Ontario into the ground, and we're all going to have to clean up the mess.


COMMENT MODERATION POLICY - Please be respectful when commenting. If choosing to remain anonymous, please sign your comment with some sort of pseudonym to avoid confusion. Please do not use any derogatory terms for fellow commenters, parties, or politicians. Inflammatory and overly partisan comments will not be posted. PLEASE KEEP DISCUSSION ON TOPIC.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.