Tuesday, September 7, 2010

The electoral race in Fredericton, Moncton, and Saint John

Some of the most hotly contested battle grounds in New Brunswick are in the province's three main cities: Fredericton, Moncton, and Saint John. Indeed, about half of the closest races in 2006's election were in these three cities. In all they represent part or all of 19 seats in the New Brunswick legislature, or more than one third. And, of course, they are the economic powerhouses of the province.

So, let's look at how people in each of these cities have voted in the last three elections.

First, Fredericton. The provincial capital has a metropolitan population of about 86,000 people, and its limits encompass part or all of five seats. The city elected mostly Liberals in the last election, so it will be necessary for the Progressive Conservatives to snatch a seat or two away from them in order to form government.But they have a difficult test ahead of them. Over the last three elections the Liberals have been on the rise in the capital, going from 38% in 1999 to 42% in 2003 and 51% in 2006. But now that the people of Fredericton have experienced a Liberal government, will their voting behaviour change?

The Progressive Conservatives were at a high of 48% in 1999, but sank to 38% in 2003. They only gained a little in 2006 so they have a 10-point gap to overcome if they want to take the lead here.

The New Democrats have a bit of a base here in the city, as they took 20% of the vote in 2003. But they lost more than of that, and most of it to the Liberals, in 2006.

Next, Moncton. The biggest city in New Brunswick with a metropolitan population of about 127,000, Moncton is home to part or all of seven seats. Both Liberals and Progressive Conservatives were elected here in 2006, so it will be a battle of offense and defense for both parties.Over the last three elections, the Progressive Conservatives have held the advantage. They dominated in 1999 with 59% of the vote but lost ten points in 2003, and were almost overtaken by the Liberals. But they grew their vote to 52% in 2006 and opened up a gap of eight points over the Liberals.

The Liberals saw big gains in 2003, going from 30% to 43%. But they were stagnant in 2006 with a gain of only one point to 44%. With the NDP vote so low, they need to take support from the Tories in order to make some new gains in the city.

The NDP does not have a good base here, earning 10% in 1999 but going from there to 8% in 2003 and 4% in 2006. They shouldn't challenge here.

Finally, Saint John. Located on the Bay of Fundy, Saint John is home to about 123,000 people and all or part of seven seats. The city elected a mix of Liberals and Progressive Conservatives in 2006, and was the home of Elizabeth Weir, the long-time only NDP MLA. So it will be a battleground for all three major parties.But the Liberals go in with the advantage, and the momentum. From 28% in 1999 the party went to 39% in 2003, making all of their gains at the expense of the Tories. Then, in 2006 the party took advantage of Weir's departure and rocketed up to 55% of the vote in the city.

The Progressive Conservatives lost a lot of support between 1999 and 2003, going from 49% to 36%. They only tread water in 2006 with 38%, so they need to make some real headway in the city if they want to elect more MLAs.

Because of Weir's history, Saint John is the NDP's best bet for an urban seat. But they need to rebuild a lot of lost support. The party was at 21% in 1999 and 23% in 2003, but fell to only 6% in 2006 in the NDP's first Weir-less election in over a decade. Can the NDP regain some of that lost support and make a surprise upset win?

Aside from a few individual riding battles, these three cities will be where the political blood is spilled. But the Liberals hold the lead in other urban areas, like Miramichi (57% in 2006 to the PC's 37%), Dieppe (50% to the PC's 47%), Campbellton (56% to the PC's 44%), and Bathurst (49% to the PC's 46%). The Tories hold the edge only in Edmundston (70% to the Liberals' 27%), meaning they either need to make some headway in New Brunswick's smaller cities or rely on a good portion of the rural vote.


  1. Idea: Could you preface the New brunswick posts with "Nb:" ? I Keep reading the feed and getting scared that Iggy is taking over.

  2. The PC candidate in Fredericton Fort Nashwaak has already stepped in it a few times. She is running in a riding on the north side of the river, but she lives on the other. She is also tried to scrub any reference from the south side from her campaign, but this before-and-after screenshot already showed up on two blogs today. Fredericton is funny in that there is a distinct difference between either side of the Saint-John River, and people tend to be loyal to their respective bank, so this could be a big issue.

    She has also gotten into it with the Liberal incumbent on Facebook. The NDP candidate Andy Scott has the same name as the popular former Lib MP (and cabinet minister) from Fredericton. She has been spreading rumors that it is the former MP running, and trying to mislead people. The two candidates had a nice little social media scrum over this on the weekend.


COMMENT MODERATION POLICY - Please be respectful when commenting. If choosing to remain anonymous, please sign your comment with some sort of pseudonym to avoid confusion. Please do not use any derogatory terms for fellow commenters, parties, or politicians. Inflammatory and overly partisan comments will not be posted. PLEASE KEEP DISCUSSION ON TOPIC.